• "The Girl on the Train" (2016) - A Deep Dive into Its Literary Devices and Mastery in Mystery Writing


    In the realm of cinematic murder mysteries, "The Girl on the Train" (2016) stands as a testament to the power of narrative techniques, casting shadows of suspense and intrigue that captivate audiences. Aspiring writers aiming to craft compelling mysteries should note the following takeaways from our exploration of this film:

    • The potency of an unreliable narrator in creating suspense.
    • The benefits of utilizing multiple perspectives to enrich the narrative.
    • The importance of setting, like the recurring motif of the train, in emphasizing character emotions and progression.
    • Crafting pacing to keep the audience on the edge of their seats.
    • The integration of deep psychological themes to provide depth beyond the primary mystery.
    • Crafting a conclusion that ties up narrative threads in a surprising yet plausible manner.

    Murder Mystery Plot Summary

    Rachel Watson's life is a blur of alcohol-induced blackouts and longing for a past she can't reclaim. Every day, she takes the train, which passes by her old house where her ex-husband, Tom, now lives with his new wife, Anna, and their child. It's not just her past home that captures her gaze, but also the house of a seemingly perfect couple a few doors down. She doesn't know them, but in her mind, they are the embodiment of love and everything she's lost.


    However, this illusion shatters when one day, from the window of the train, Rachel witnesses something unsettling in the couple's backyard. The next thing she knows, she wakes up at home covered in blood with no memory of the previous night. Soon, she learns from the news that the woman from the 'perfect' couple, Megan Hipwell, has gone missing.


    The plot spirals into a web of deception, betrayal, and murder as Rachel becomes entangled in the investigation. Her alcoholism makes her an unreliable witness, if not a suspect. As she struggles to piece together her fragmented memories, it becomes evident that the lives of Rachel, Anna, and Megan are intricately connected in ways she could never have imagined.


    Throughout the story, Rachel's desperate quest for the truth not only uncovers Megan's fate but also leads to self-discovery and redemption. The film gracefully navigates the intricacies of memory, perception, and the dark corners of human nature, culminating in a revelation that's both shocking and poignant.

    Analyzing the Murder Mystery

    "The Girl on the Train" does more than just present a straightforward whodunnit; it immerses the audience in a narrative brimming with unreliable memories, layered characters, and intertwining lives, all of which serve as puzzle pieces in the grander mystery of Megan Hipwell's disappearance.

    1. Unreliable Narrator: Central to the film's mystery is its primary protagonist, Rachel. Her alcoholism renders her memories fragmented and unreliable, providing a haze of uncertainty that looms over the narrative. This technique amplifies the suspense as neither Rachel nor the audience can confidently discern reality from misremembered events.
    2. Multiple Perspectives: One of the standout elements of the narrative structure is the use of multiple viewpoints. The film doesn't solely rely on Rachel's perspective; it intertwines her story with that of Megan and Anna. These shifting viewpoints ensure that the audience gets a multifaceted view of events, character motivations, and relationships, making the mystery all the more complex and engaging.
    3. The Train as a Symbol: The recurring motif of the train is not just a device to move the plot forward but serves as a metaphorical element in the mystery. The train, with its repetitive journey and fleeting glances into people's lives, symbolizes Rachel's own state of mind — her cyclical despair, her brief windows into others' lives, and her desire for movement and change. It is from this train that the initial mystery springs forth, with Rachel's glimpse of Megan's apparent infidelity.
    4. Deep-Seated Motivations: At its core, "The Girl on the Train" isn't just about finding out what happened to Megan; it's a deep dive into the psyches of its central characters. Their past traumas, infidelities, desires, and despairs all contribute to the unfolding mystery, making the revelations not just about external events but deeply rooted psychological motivations.
    5. Red Herrings: As with any great mystery, the narrative is filled with misleading clues and false leads. From Rachel's blackouts and violent tendencies to Anna's potential motives and Megan's intricate relationships, the audience is constantly challenged to discern the truth amidst a sea of misdirection.
    6. Resolution: Without venturing into spoiler territory, the culmination of the film's mystery is both unexpected and chilling. It showcases the depths to which human emotion can drive individuals, ensuring that the revelation is not just surprising but also emotionally resonant. The clues were all there, subtly laid out, but the true art lies in how they're pieced together in the end.

    Key Takeaways for Aspiring Murder Mystery Writers

    Drawing from the intricate web of deception, personal histories, and motivations in "The Girl on the Train", there are several crucial elements that can guide budding mystery writers:

    1. Complex Characters are Key: A memorable murder mystery goes beyond just an engaging plot; it delves into the psyche of its characters. Rachel's character, with her flaws, vulnerabilities, and unreliable memories, serves as the heartbeat of the story. She's not just a passive observer; her personal struggles intertwine with the larger mystery, making the resolution all the more impactful. Aspiring writers should focus on crafting characters with depth, internal conflicts, and hidden facets that can be unraveled over time.
    2. Unreliable Elements Elevate Suspense: Using an unreliable narrator or incorporating unreliable elements can significantly heighten the suspense. It brings about a sense of unpredictability, where every revelation must be questioned and re-evaluated, keeping the readers or viewers on their toes.
    3. Layer Your Narrative: A single perspective can be limiting in a mystery. By offering multiple viewpoints, like in the case of Rachel, Megan, and Anna, writers can create a richer, more layered narrative. It provides the audience with multiple pieces of a jigsaw puzzle, challenging them to put it together.
    4. Symbols and Motifs Add Depth: The train in the film isn’t just a mode of transport; it symbolizes Rachel's life, her fleeting insights into others' lives, and her desire for a fresh start. Using such symbols can add layers of meaning to your story, making it richer and more profound.
    5. Misdirection is Essential: A well-placed red herring can keep the audience guessing, making the final revelation even more striking. But it's essential for these misleading clues to be plausible and woven seamlessly into the narrative.
    6. Emotional Resonance: While the mystery's resolution is vital, how it emotionally impacts the characters and, in turn, the audience, is what makes it memorable. Whether it's the shock, relief, despair, or a mix of emotions, the ending should resonate on an emotional level, making the journey worthwhile.

    In conclusion, "The Girl on the Train" offers more than just a gripping mystery; it serves as a masterclass in character development, narrative layering, and emotional storytelling. Aspiring writers can draw from its strengths to craft mysteries that not only intrigue but also deeply resonate.


    Jonesing to live-out your own murder mystery experience?

    Check out the best murder mystery party themes in the game!