"Knives Out": Dissecting the Modern Mastery of Murder Mystery

    In the cinematic realm of mystery and suspense, "Knives Out" (2019) stands as a testament to the enduring allure of the whodunit genre. Aspiring writers looking to delve into the world of murder mystery can glean several insights from this modern masterpiece. Among the most striking elements to be discussed in this article are:

    • The art of subverting classic tropes.
    • The significance of deeply layered characters.
    • The role of setting as more than just a backdrop.
    • The interplay between suspense and humor.
    • The incorporation of real-world themes into a murder mystery.
    • The meticulous attention to detail in plotting.

    Summarizing the Murder Mystery Plot:

    In the heart of a grand mansion, the Thrombey family gathers to celebrate the 85th birthday of their patriarch, Harlan Thrombey. However, the festivities take a dark turn when Harlan is found dead the next morning. Initially deemed a suicide, the circumstances surrounding Harlan's demise soon grow questionable.


    Enter the charismatic and perceptive Detective Benoit Blanc. Hired by an anonymous source, Blanc embarks on a journey to uncover the truth, navigating the labyrinthine secrets of the Thrombey family. Each member, from Harlan's children to his grandchildren, carries potential motives, further complicating the investigation.


    Central to the narrative is Marta Cabrera, Harlan's caregiver. She finds herself involuntarily tangled in the family's disputes and the investigation, especially given her peculiar inability to lie without a physical reaction. As the plot unfolds, what seemed like a straightforward case becomes a tangled web of deception, greed, and hidden agendas. The climax is both a revelation of the truth behind Harlan's death and a spotlight on the mastermind orchestrating the events from the shadows.

    Analyzing the Murder Mystery

    "Knives Out" revitalizes the murder mystery genre by masterfully blending traditional elements with unexpected twists. Here's a deeper dive into the film's key components:

    1. Subversion of Tropes: At first glance, "Knives Out" presents as a classic whodunit—a rich old man dies under suspicious circumstances, and everyone in the house is a suspect. However, director Rian Johnson quickly subverts expectations. Instead of saving the "big reveal" for the end, a significant portion of the mystery is disclosed halfway through, shifting the focus from "who did it" to "how will they get caught."
    2. Character Depth and Motive: Rather than presenting a lineup of suspects with superficial motives, "Knives Out" delves deep into the Thrombey family's dynamics. Every member has a motive rooted in personal relationships, financial dependencies, and long-held grudges. This intricate character development adds layers to the narrative, making each revelation more impactful.
    3. Setting as Character: The Thrombey mansion isn't just a backdrop—it plays an active role in the story. Its labyrinthine layout, hidden doors, and the titular "donut hole" metaphor all mirror the convoluted relationships and secrets within the family.
    4. Balancing Suspense and Humor: "Knives Out" skillfully balances tension with humor, ensuring that the audience remains engaged but never overwhelmed. Characters like Detective Blanc, with his enigmatic Southern drawl, add levity, making the film as much a comedy as it is a thriller.
    5. Contemporary Themes: The film does not shy away from addressing modern-day topics, such as class division, immigration, and entitlement. Marta's character becomes an embodiment of these themes, as the Thrombeys' faux-allyship and their disregard for her ethnicity are highlighted.
    6. Attention to Detail: Every element in "Knives Out" is meticulously crafted. From Marta's inability to lie without vomiting—which plays a pivotal role in the climax—to the subtle hints dropped throughout the film, Johnson ensures that attentive viewers are rewarded for their keen observation.

    By melding these elements, "Knives Out" not only entertains but also challenges the audience to think, reflect, and piece together the puzzle along with Detective Blanc.

    Key Takeaways for Aspiring Murder Mystery Writers

    "Knives Out" is not just a testament to the enduring appeal of the murder mystery genre, but also a masterclass in how to innovate within a well-trodden narrative landscape. Here's what budding writers can glean from its brilliance:

    1. Embrace and Subvert Tropes: While it's tempting to completely revolutionize the traditional murder mystery format, "Knives Out" demonstrates the power of building on established tropes, only to subvert them. This approach not only pays homage to the genre's roots but also keeps audiences on their toes.
    2. Character Complexity is Key: A good mystery is as much about the 'why' as the 'who'. By diving deep into character backgrounds, motivations, and flaws, you not only create a richer narrative but also offer readers or viewers multifaceted suspects that heighten the intrigue.
    3. Utilize Setting to Enhance Narrative: Your setting can be more than just a backdrop—it can be a silent character, influencing the narrative and reflecting broader themes. Consider how your environment can play an active role in unfolding events.
    4. Blend Genres for Freshness: Combining elements of humor, drama, and suspense can make your story multidimensional and cater to a broader audience. The trick is to find the right balance so one doesn't overshadow the other.
    5. Embed Contemporary Issues: Grounding your mystery in real-world themes can add a layer of relevance and urgency to your story. It's a way to comment on societal issues while still delivering a gripping tale.
    6. Reward Attention to Detail: Readers and viewers who are investing time in your story will appreciate intricate details that come full circle. Think about the breadcrumbs you can leave that would make the final reveal even more satisfying for the attentive audience.
    7. Stay True to the Core Mystery: While subplots and character arcs are essential, never lose sight of the central mystery. Ensure that every twist and turn, every character, and every detail ultimately serves the primary narrative.

    Drawing inspiration from "Knives Out" and its innovative approach to storytelling can offer aspiring writers a roadmap to crafting a murder mystery that is both familiar and refreshingly new. Remember, the genre's boundaries are only as limited as your imagination.


    Jonesing to live-out your own murder mystery experience?

    Check out the best murder mystery party themes in the game!